Fear Street: 1994

Kiana Madeira Deena Olivia Scott Welch Samantha Fraser Benjamin Flores Jr. Josh Julia Rehwald Kate Fred Hechinger Simon Maya Hawke Heather Charlene Amoia Rachel Thompson / Sunnyvale Customer David Thompson Ryan Torres Noah Bain Garret Skull Mask Darrell Britt-Gibson Martin Ashley Zukerman Nick Goode Jana Allen TV Reporter #1 Matt Burke Football Coach Christian Bridges Fun Shadyside Football Player Matthew Zuk Mayor Will Goode Jeremy Ford Peter Jaime Matthis Shadyside Player Danyon Huntington Sunnyvale Skullmask Elizabeth Scopel Sarah Fier Tayla Rogers The Babysitting Twin Maya Rogers The Babysitting Twin Jordana Spiro Mrs. Lane Diane Sellers Check In Nurse Eric Mendenhall Nurse Beddy Todd Allen Durkin Officer Kapinsky Jordyn DiNatale Ruby Lane Lloyd Pitts Nightwing Killer Kevin Waterman 'The Milkman' Harry Rooker Emily Brobst Billy Barker Keil Oakley Zepernick 'Shame Killer' Isaac Milton Michael Chandler 'The Pastor' Cyrus Miller Lacy Camp Mrs. Fraser Meghan Packer TV Reporter #2 Gillian Jacobs C. Berman (voice) Sadie Sink Ziggy Berman (uncredited)