Our Little Secret

Lindsay Lohan Avery Ian Harding Logan Kristin Chenoweth Erica Jon Rudnitsky Cameron Dan Bucatinsky Leonard Jake Brennan Callum Judy Reyes Margaret Katie Baker Cassie Tim Meadows Stan Ash Santos Sophie Henry Czerny Mitchell Bobbie Eakes Cheryl Brian Unger Paul Chris Parnell Veterinarian Melinda Tanner Ida Mim Drew Susan Kurt Yue Priest Nathan Alexander Tutterrow Altar Boy Jade Fernandez Holly Kimberly Donyale Middle Aged Woman Sunny Williams Church Lady Leah Selene Nativity Kid Warren Abercrombie Construction Man Christopher Deforest Choir Member Roy Jenkins Choir Member Corrie Henson Choir Member Janeen Michael Choir Member Jasper Randall Choir Member Kathy J. Carey Choir Member Mark Blankenship Choir Member Rachael Chao Choir Member Rita Shealy Choir Member Sonya Da Silva Choir Member Steve Adam Henson Choir Member Tim Ellis Choir Member Wendy Young McKinnon Choir Member