An American Crime

Elliot Page Sylvia Likens Catherine Keener Gertrude Baniszewski Hayley McFarland Jennifer Faye 'Jennie' Likens Nick Searcy Lester Likens Romy Rosemont Betty Likens Ari Graynor Paula Baniszewski Scout Taylor-Compton Stephanie Baniszewski Tristan Jarred Johnny Baniszewski Hannah Leigh Shirley Baniszewski Bradley Whitford Prosecutor James Franco Andy Scott Eastwood Eric Michael O'Keefe Reverend Bill Collier Carlie Westerman Marie Baniszewski Michelle Benes Hope Orbach Jeremy Sumpter Coy Hubbard Brian Geraghty Bradley Channing Nichols Patty Michael Welch Teddy Evan Peters Ricky Hobbs Amy Ferguson Sally Will Carter Officer Waters Edward James Gage Bailiff Patricia Place Mrs. Doyle Paul Grace Cottin Candy Vendor (uncredited) James Meehan Defense Attorney (uncredited) Paul Palo Newspaper Reporter (uncredited) Gary Sievers Carnie (uncredited)